Speak EV - Electric Car Forums banner
1 - 20 of 38 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
121 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
This is likely a dumb question. Is there a way that my 2018 40kw Leaf can make full use of the public chargers capable of charging at 22kw?

Happy Christmas seeing as I'm posting this on Christmas Day!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,056 Posts
This is likely a dumb question. Is there a way that my 2018 40kw Leaf can make full use of the public chargers capable of charging at 22kw?

Happy Christmas seeing as I'm posting this on Christmas Day!
No.

22kW is incredibly rare. Basically the Zoe, optional extra on early Tesla Model S, optional extra on Porsche Taycan.

Your LEAF maxes out at 6.6kW (I believe).
 

· Registered
Joined
·
121 Posts
Discussion Starter · #4 ·
No.

22kW is incredibly rare. Basically the Zoe, optional extra on early Tesla Model S, optional extra on Porsche Taycan.

Your LEAF maxes out at 6.6kW (I believe).
Oh right. I feel less of a chump for buying a Leaf now with its "betamax" Chademo rapid charging. At least I'm not alone in being unable to use the 22 kw charging to its full extent.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,056 Posts
Oh right. I feel less of a chump for buying a Leaf now with its "betamax" Chademo rapid charging. At least I'm not alone in being unable to use the 22 kw charging to its full extent.
22kW was a bigger deal when you could charge for free at Tesco. Now that has gone, so long as you wake up to a full charge in the morning, who cares how fast the fast-charging is?
 

· Registered
Joined
·
287 Posts
I'm tempted by the Muxsan ccs upgrade, together with a battery upgrade, rather than a ccs car, but largely because (and it's very niche) of the Chademo V2G.
There's also something cool about having both CCS and Chademo, but whether that's worth the 5 grand (if I remember rightly) it costs is another question...
 

· Registered
Joined
·
537 Posts
The 22kW charging uses three phase. So, if you wanted to upgrade a car from 7kW charging, you'd need to add 2 more charge modules or replace the original single phase unit with a 3-phase one.
It's a shame the 22kW charging wasn't more widely adopted by car makers, as 415v 3-phase supplies are of course very common on commercial sites.
I'm in the Chademo club too. I don't see anything wrong with it, and can honestly say CCS has no advantage for me with my car. I don't travel long distances where I need to fast-charge away from home, and assume most other people with 30kWh (or under) batteries are in the same situation.
Nissan's 40 and 62kWh packs are a bit oddball to me, as the range encourages travelling further away from the safety of home charging, knowing that public Chademo units are being phased out.
I suppose the moral of this EV story is like always: do your research to get the car that suits your needs.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
121 Posts
Discussion Starter · #13 ·
No.

22kW is incredibly rare. Basically the Zoe, optional extra on early Tesla Model S, optional extra on Porsche Taycan.
A few months back in Whitby they fitted the first public charger of more than 7kw and it's a 22kw one. North Yorkshire council have announced they are putting in "rapid chargers" in some of their car parks including Whitby and it turns out they will be 22kw chargers.

It sounds daft when from what you say hardly anyone will be able to make full use of them only being able to charge at 7kw.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
121 Posts
Discussion Starter · #14 ·
The 22kW charging uses three phase. So, if you wanted to upgrade a car from 7kW charging, you'd need to add 2 more charge modules or replace the original single phase unit with a 3-phase one.
It's a shame the 22kW charging wasn't more widely adopted by car makers, as 415v 3-phase supplies are of course very common on commercial sites.
I'm in the Chademo club too. I don't see anything wrong with it, and can honestly say CCS has no advantage for me with my car. I don't travel long distances where I need to fast-charge away from home, and assume most other people with 30kWh (or under) batteries are in the same situation.
Nissan's 40 and 62kWh packs are a bit oddball to me, as the range encourages travelling further away from the safety of home charging, knowing that public Chademo units are being phased out.
I suppose the moral of this EV story is like always: do your research to get the car that suits your needs.
In my ten months of ownership of a 2018 Leaf I've not been far in it so it's been fine for me.

If places like Lidl continue to have machines which only allow one rapid charge at a time I guess they won't care so much if less and less often the Chademo plug is being used?
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,317 Posts
Oh right. I feel less of a chump for buying a Leaf now with its "betamax" Chademo rapid charging.
Just out of interest, and may be of benefit to other potential purchasers, when did you understand the nuances of rapid charging standards and that the leaf couldn't charge on all networks? Presumably the sales person didn't make particular mention as they'd be losing a sale if they raised the subject of Chademo vs CCS! Would you have bought the car if you had been made aware of it?

Also don't forget the Zoe40 and even some of the Zoe50 cars don't have CCS either. At least one new owner of a Zoe50 has been shocked to discover they couldn't use CCS after buying the car!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
121 Posts
Discussion Starter · #16 ·
What's your leaf worth now and how much would you lose from your purchase if you sold it now?


Just out of interest, and may be of benefit to other potential purchasers, when did you understand the nuances of rapid charging standards and that the leaf couldn't charge on all networks? Presumably the sales person didn't make particular mention as they'd be losing a sale if they raised the subject of Chademo vs CCS! Would you have bought the car if you had been made aware of it?

Also don't forget the Zoe40 and even some of the Zoe50 cars don't have CCS either. At least one new owner of a Zoe50 has been shocked to discover they couldn't use CCS after buying the car!
I didn't imagine driving the car long distances much if at all so clearly I wasn't thinking enough about rapid charging. I didn't know that the Leaf's way of rapid charging was on the way out when I bought the car. It is niggling that there might come a time when I want to do a round trip of 200 miles in a day and it isn't possible in this car.
 

· Registered
Vauxhall Vivaro Cargo 50kwh, Corsa Anniversary
Joined
·
1,621 Posts
A few months back in Whitby they fitted the first public charger of more than 7kw and it's a 22kw one. North Yorkshire council have announced they are putting in "rapid chargers" in some of their car parks including Whitby and it turns out they will be 22kw chargers.

It sounds daft when from what you say hardly anyone will be able to make full use of them only being able to charge at 7kw.
3 phase is standard in most of Europe, so many European cars (including the Corsa I have on order, and I think most Stellantis and VAG cars) can charge faster than 7kw, with the right cable. The Corsa can charge at 7kw single phase, or 3x3.6kw for 11kw at a 22kw charger, though I don't know if it'll come with a thicker 3 phase cable. I'm not bothered either way - at home I'll charge at 7kw, and on long journeys I'll use DC charging at 50-100kw.
 

· Registered
Vauxhall Vivaro Cargo 50kwh, Corsa Anniversary
Joined
·
1,621 Posts
At least one new owner of a Zoe50 has been shocked to discover they couldn't use CCS after buying the car!
Doesn't that do 43kw AC charging? Barely slower than the 50kw max DC charging the CCS equipped Zoe can manage, so on paper it seems fine. Though I'm not sure I've ever seen a 43kw AC charger, which shows that reality isn't quite the same as theory, and research is important. I discounted the Zoe early on in my search, mainly due to the 50kw max, but also due to the EuroNCAP score. Having driven a 50kw max short range MG5 650 miles in a day, it turns out 50kw is fine, and I could have had it almost a year ago. If I hadn't already agreed a superb price for a Corsa, I'd cancel and buy an MG4 instead, but that would cost an extra £6000, so I'll be patient. I've only waited 10 months so far...
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,056 Posts
Still loads in Scotland on the CPS network and mostly priced the same as 7kW units. A bit of an oddity...?
It is all part of the journey. We seem to have ended up with AC charging limited to 7kW single-phase or 11kW 3-phase to be used for overnight charging at home or a hotel. And 100kW+ rapid-charging while you’re on the road for long trips.

I personally think there is room for 22kW charging for places like IKEA, or restaurants, or cinemas, or whatever. Basically places where you stop for an hour-or-two. But it seems to have died out.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
537 Posts
In my ten months of ownership of a 2018 Leaf I've not been far in it so it's been fine for me.
Precisely, same here! Home charging is fine for us. In the event that I wanted to go on a long journey, I'd either research the hell out of working Chademo fast chargers, or more likely take our diesel car.
 
1 - 20 of 38 Posts
Top