Speak EV - Electric Car Forums banner

221 - 240 of 244 Posts

·
EGGY
Joined
·
979 Posts
Just called them, they have apparently been advised that HV is now covered and will confirm via mail, revised warranty documents not yet produced so they cannot send a copy out yet
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,905 Posts
Just called them, they have apparently been advised that HV is now covered and will confirm via mail, revised warranty documents not yet produced so they cannot send a copy out yet
I am not sure that I would accept what could be a fundamental change to the terms of a contract based on someone in CS - who may be on sales commission - saying that they will confirm the change by e-mail. But then again, I am just naturally cautious.
 

·
EGGY
Joined
·
979 Posts
Yup I share your concerns, here's the reply:

In response to your questions, I can confirm that if you decided you would like to renew the warranty you would be covered by two warranties.

The BMW Extended warranty sold by Allianz would not cover high voltage batteries and external cables under the extended warranty. Internal high voltage cables will be covered under the warranty .

In regards to the other questions outlined in this email I will need to refer you to our customer services team who are well informed on the BMW I-Battery warranty and the original battery warranty on this vehicle.

Customer services :0800 325 600
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,905 Posts
Yup I share your concerns, here's the reply:

In response to your questions, I can confirm that if you decided you would like to renew the warranty you would be covered by two warranties.

The BMW Extended warranty sold by Allianz would not cover high voltage batteries and external cables under the extended warranty. Internal high voltage cables will be covered under the warranty .

In regards to the other questions outlined in this email I will need to refer you to our customer services team who are well informed on the BMW I-Battery warranty and the original battery warranty on this vehicle.

Customer services :0800 325 600
The first part of the response is re-assuring as it appears to accord with the warranty ts and cs in that HV internal cables are not excluded items. They have though failed to mention that the 12 volt battery is also excluded from the insured warranty. It will be interesting to see if the warranty document is actually updated.


Sadly, this is a situation that could get complicated with 2 warranties. This is a report of a Drivetrain failure followed by a total loss of propulsion on a 2014 BEV with 37,000 miles on the odometer in the States. Six weeks on, this is what was posted:

Quote: Here it is 6 weeks later and I just got my car back from the dealer.
:D
Over the last 6 weeks they tried a variety of fixes, and each time the car tried to kill the service tech by shutting down with each attempt. Finally they surrendered and replaced the THE WHOLE BATTERY PACK (of which I was told was a $35K fix) and gave me back the car this morning. Before this last service call happened I had offered to let them by the car back at a reasonable price, but seeing how the bluebook value of my $50,000 car has plummeted to below $13K
:o
, they only laughed (along with BMWUSA) and handed me back the keys. But hey, at 36,600 miles at least I have a new pack.
:roll:
Unquote

One can only hope that the Insured Warranty provider would take ownership of the problem and deal with BMW as necessary. Clearly, BMW dealing with its own insured warranty provider would probably be less fraught than dealing with A N Other. That said, this was a 2014 BEV and there were known issues with 2014 models.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
261 Posts
I agree, I'm going to pay up and spend the next year looking for a new car
Yes, that’s exactly the way we looked at it......BMW one year warranty for the cost of third party three year warranty, and TBH I am not sure we will keep it for more than another year, I am hoping (most likely in vain) that being a BMW “named” warranty it might be a better experience if needed, and we get the BMW recovery service.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,263 Posts
It is worth factoring in to your thinking the cost of the BMW Insured Warranty versus the depreciation on a new EV. I traded up after 4 years because I wanted the increased EV range.
The old adage for cost effective motoring with minimum contact with garages for money draining repairs was 'buy at two and sell at five'. That way you avoided the worst of the deprection and the likely worst of the bigger later repairs. For an i3 I think it might have to be 'buy at two and sell at four' because of cost and probability of repair. Also switching so as to delete the need for a REx by going from a 94Ah REx to a 120Ah makes the decision even more finely balanced since the replacement car ought to be more reliable and you have a battery that is two years younger in respect of decay. I am working on a target of running an i3 and keeping the cost per mile below 50p.

Most of that is depreciation. I wonder what sort of figure other i3 drivers are coming out with? I am assuming for two to four years a £2k a year depreciation plus a £1500 margin for the dealer taking a trade-in.

What sort of repairs are folk encountering in practice (if any) in year three to four?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
61 Posts
I am reading the policy document for the comprehensive warranty and I cannot find where it says internal HV cables are covered, is this covered under the battery warranty?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,905 Posts
I am reading the policy document for the comprehensive warranty and I cannot find where it says internal HV cables are covered, is this covered under the battery warranty?
It doesn't, but that is not what is being said. The BMW Insured Warranty (Comprehensive) does not exclude the HV cables but it does exclude the HV battery. The latter is covered by the 8 year battery warranty which does not include HV cables. After 3 years, replacement of the 12volt battery is one for the owner.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2 Posts
so, after reading all 12 pages, i'm still not sure if an i3 is a good buy? Just looking for experienced owners opinions. i'm looking at 2014 rex has all the packages i want with 34k miles on it. BMW battery warranty is only 8 years leaving 2 years pretty much left. So are third party warranties worth it for the i3(ev's) these days? hv cables covered or not, batteries covered after normal 8 year warranty runs out? Is an i3 worth it at this year and price, or should be avoided?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,905 Posts
so, after reading all 12 pages, i'm still not sure if an i3 is a good buy? Just looking for experienced owners opinions. i'm looking at 2014 rex has all the packages i want with 34k miles on it. BMW battery warranty is only 8 years leaving 2 years pretty much left. So are third party warranties worth it for the i3(ev's) these days? hv cables covered or not, batteries covered after normal 8 year warranty runs out? Is an i3 worth it at this year and price, or should be avoided?
My advice would be to look for a REx from 2015 onwards. The 2014 REx had a number of issues. That said, it comes down to your attitude to risk; the car’s repair history and the asking price. It is also worth pointing out that the battery warranty on a 2014 i3 kicks in once the battery state of charge falls below 70% of the usable SOC (18.8 X 70%). If this was to happen (unlikely imho), then the actual loss of battery charge would be closer to 40%.
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
11,093 Posts
i'm looking at 2014 rex has all the packages i want with 34k miles on it. BMW battery warranty is only 8 years leaving 2 years pretty much left.
My suggestion is to avoid one that old at any price.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
118 Posts
My suggestion is to avoid one that old at any price.
100% agree. If by some miracle you avoid the hugely expensive faults, you'll have a car that's impossible to shift unless you make it incredibly cheap. There are several very well-known and very £££ weaknesses with first-production-run 2014 REX cars that make them lemony compared to other choices. More mileage and later for the same money is a much better strategy.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2 Posts
thanks for all the advice/info. I will be avoiding that one i was looking at. Searching for newer models now that have the right colour,alloys, media, parking, sunroof etc.
Here's the advert if anyone was interested :
2014 I3 autotrader
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,702 Posts
Or similar for £5k less... which is the price of a new Rex if it has an issue, pocket the cash and leave it in an ISA as your warranty!


Would have a look here if you have not already.
 
221 - 240 of 244 Posts
Top