Speak EV - Electric Car Forums banner
1 - 16 of 16 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
4 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Hi,

My wife and I live about an hour north of Glasgow and have made the decision to switch to electric. We have a diesel Subaru Outback and a Fiat Panda 4x4 but they’re going soon -a Tesla is on the way within a month with something small for me to runabout in for work. It’s pretty mountainy where we are and I’m looking for something that can handle a 30 mile each way trip a few times a week - this commute has a 400m climb each way, single track wi lots of stopping/starting on the return leg. I’ve looked at a few of the less expensive options and I’m a wee bit unsure of how well they’ll do on the uphills and whether there’s any prospect of battery regen on the way down the hills ?

We’re all in on this change, it’s something we should’ve done some time ago but we cannot wait to get into it.

All the best

TB
 

·
Registered
MG5
Joined
·
1,318 Posts
Hi,
We have got an MG5 and the regeneration on it is great 👍
 
  • Like
Reactions: TighBoidheach

·
Registered
Kia E-Niro 2021 4+
Joined
·
342 Posts
Hello and welcome!
I can only speak for a Niro but driving it on single track “roller coaster” roads in Yorkshire and Lake District this week has been a joy. We hadn’t fully appreciated this benefit of EVs living in East Anglia!!
It has been an utter pleasure gliding effortlessly up steep twisty hills and then re-genning down again barely needing to brake. Need to stop half way up a hill for a wandering sheep? No drama. Just stop, then move off again without the 🥵 of a hill start on a 1:10 slope!
Hope your journey into EV land is as fun and happy as ours has been.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,360 Posts
Hi,

My wife and I live about an hour north of Glasgow and have made the decision to switch to electric. We have a diesel Subaru Outback and a Fiat Panda 4x4 but they’re going soon -a Tesla is on the way within a month with something small for me to runabout in for work. It’s pretty mountainy where we are and I’m looking for something that can handle a 30 mile each way trip a few times a week - this commute has a 400m climb each way, single track wi lots of stopping/starting on the return leg. I’ve looked at a few of the less expensive options and I’m a wee bit unsure of how well they’ll do on the uphills and whether there’s any prospect of battery regen on the way down the hills ?

We’re all in on this change, it’s something we should’ve done some time ago but we cannot wait to get into it.

All the best

TB
Have you considered an electric helicopter?

Seriously, where is the commute to, what is it like in winter?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4 Posts
Discussion Starter · #6 ·
Have you considered an electric helicopter?

Seriously, where is the commute to, what is it like in winter?
Winter can be pretty bad here, heavy snow, wind etc.The car probably won’t be required then, if I do have to travel in bad weather the Tesla will have to do the job. What I’m after is something at around the £10k mark that can cope with hills and stop/start driving - not unusual around here. Occasionally I might need to go a bit further also so a genuine battery life that’ll get me around the 60 mile mark comfortably is required.

I don’t like helicopters so that’s not an option either although where I drive to does have a helipad.

Thanks for the replies, I’m off this arvo to have a look at a 30kwh Leaf which May do the trick.

Slàinte

TB
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,360 Posts
Winter can be pretty bad here, heavy snow, wind etc.The car probably won’t be required then, if I do have to travel in bad weather the Tesla will have to do the job. What I’m after is something at around the £10k mark that can cope with hills and stop/start driving - not unusual around here. Occasionally I might need to go a bit further also so a genuine battery life that’ll get me around the 60 mile mark comfortably is required.

I don’t like helicopters so that’s not an option either although where I drive to does have a helipad.

Thanks for the replies, I’m off this arvo to have a look at a 30kwh Leaf which May do the trick.

Slàinte

TB
Aye, Leaf30 is a good place to start for the 2nd BEV. Winter Tyres make all the difference. Get a chargepoint installed at your work too.
 

·
Registered
2012 24kw upgraded to 40kw
Joined
·
447 Posts
Winter can be pretty bad here, heavy snow, wind etc.The car probably won’t be required then, if I do have to travel in bad weather the Tesla will have to do the job. What I’m after is something at around the £10k mark that can cope with hills and stop/start driving - not unusual around here. Occasionally I might need to go a bit further also so a genuine battery life that’ll get me around the 60 mile mark comfortably is required.

I don’t like helicopters so that’s not an option either although where I drive to does have a helipad.

Thanks for the replies, I’m off this arvo to have a look at a 30kwh Leaf which May do the trick.

Slàinte

TB
I'd agree with the others that a Leaf with winter tyres (or even Michelin Crossclimate - or similar all-season tyres) will manage well in snow. The key thing to keep in mind that at Scottish winter temperatures, the battery gives less range (by about 20%) and you tend to use the heater more (though a decent down jacket works for me...). I've done a reasonable amount of singletrack in my Leaf and love not needing to muck about with gears, plus you'll find the regen can be enough to avoid using the brakes for ages. But, if you blast up the hills, you'll use more battery than if you take it easy.
 

·
Registered
2012 24kw upgraded to 40kw
Joined
·
447 Posts
I'd suggest that you register and get a card from Chargeplace Scotland - these enable you to access a fairly large charger network (some of these are still free, others charge depending upon the local authority). The card seems to work better than the app, and the service was recently taken over by Swarco.

 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
8,017 Posts
I used to commute from Taynuilt to Tarbert and avoided the main roads due to the timber lorries, by taking the north or south road down Loch Awe.
It was a pain in the neck in my ICE vehicles, (DS3 1.2, Alfa Brera 3.2, Guilietta 1750tbi, Citroen C5 V6 auto and a VW Camper) due to the endless gearchanging and speed variation from below 20 to around 45.

However I recently have driven the south road from Cladich to Ford and on to Ardern a couple of times in the Leaf and it was very pleasant. Smooth, always in the correct gear (as there is only the one!) and effortless, with the 1pedal mode avoiding the need to use the brakes.
You'll kick yourself for not taking the plunger sooner.
 

·
Registered
Leaf e+tekna 62kwh.
Joined
·
40 Posts
Hi,

My wife and I live about an hour north of Glasgow and have made the decision to switch to electric. We have a diesel Subaru Outback and a Fiat Panda 4x4 but they’re going soon -a Tesla is on the way within a month with something small for me to runabout in for work. It’s pretty mountainy where we are and I’m looking for something that can handle a 30 mile each way trip a few times a week - this commute has a 400m climb each way, single track wi lots of stopping/starting on the return leg. I’ve looked at a few of the less expensive options and I’m a wee bit unsure of how well they’ll do on the uphills and whether there’s any prospect of battery regen on the way down the hills ?

We’re all in on this change, it’s something we should’ve done some time ago but we cannot wait to get into it.

All the best

TB
Maybe time to move house.😁
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4 Posts
Discussion Starter · #15 ·
Maybe time to move house.😁
Hi, Nope, we’re staying here until death - whenever that is.

Progress has been slow but I’m now the owner of a 17 plate 30kwh Leaf. It’s early days but things seem good so far. The range falls off a cliff uphill but down the other side is great. It drives well enough and should be easy to live with. Charging at home is not exactly intuitive - we don’t have a charging point installed yet - but it works. Picked it up from Stirling and on the 50 odd mile journey home the range and actual miles driven tallied almost exactly. Car indicates 118 range from full charge.

Let’s see how things progress.

Ta 👍🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4 Posts
Discussion Starter · #16 ·
Latest: Made the work journey a few times now, in both good and bad weather. Been driving in D and B modes wi Eco setting selected.

First 10ish miles are more or less flat on a narrow twisty A road. Going much slower than previously but range holding steady. Next bit is around 5 miles uphill. Going gently and maybe 20-25 miles of range down. The following downhill section recovers around 10 miles of range before levelling out for the final 3 miles.

All good then, just going quite slowly is fine. Getting the charging point installed next week. Looks like I can do comfortably 2 round trips on around a 80% charge without worrying about it.

My wife was due to take delivery of a model 3 Tesla in the next week or so but as expected they’re now saying it’ll be 7 weeks - and the shipment has not left China yet. We’re aware of the covid related port delays so even 7 weeks sounds optimistic imo.

Thanks and more updates as and when
 
1 - 16 of 16 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top