Speak EV - Electric Car Forums banner
1 - 20 of 52 Posts

· Registered
Kia Niro EV '4' 2022
Joined
·
1,765 Posts
I wouldn't.

But if its a rare event it wouldn't matter too much in the great scheme of things. The issue for the battery is how much of its life it spends at 100%.

But if you have the means to charge it on Sunday, why would you charge it tonight? Its a minimal risk to the battery's health but an avoidable one.
 

· Registered
Kia Niro EV '4' 2022
Joined
·
1,765 Posts
It'll be fine. We got our Ioniq just before first lockdown in 2020, it was sat at 100% for the duration (3 months?) and no problems at all after, started first time, even 12v was okay.
It might have started fine but it's very likely you did the battery no favours at all being sat at 100% for 3 months. The fact it started fine is not an indication that it was not a problem to do that.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
656 Posts
Discussion Starter · #6 ·
The only problem with Sunday/Monday is that we are leaving early and I dare not forget anything - such as wrapping up the cable and stowing it in the boot!.Also, the small possibility of an overnight mains glitch that terminates charging leaving me 'stuffed'. Maybe the best compromise is Sat-Sun.

Lawrence
 

· Registered
Kia Niro EV '4' 2022
Joined
·
1,765 Posts
The only problem with Sunday/Monday is that we are leaving early and I dare not forget anything - such as wrapping up the cable and stowing it in the boot!.Also, the small possibility of an overnight mains glitch that terminates charging leaving me 'stuffed'. Maybe the best compromise is Sat-Sun.

Lawrence
Why don't you take it up to around 85% tonight or tomorrow night and then top it on Sunday afternoon / early evening before you go to bed. For the last 15%, even if it's at peak rate, you'd only be looking at a couple of extra quid.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
656 Posts
Discussion Starter · #9 ·
Why don't you take it up to around 85% tonight or tomorrow night and then top it on Sunday afternoon / early evening before you go to bed. For the last 15%, even if it's at peak rate, you'd only be looking at a couple of extra quid.
Curiously, I had just decided to do that! Best compromise.

Lawrence
 

· Registered
Joined
·
383 Posts
It might have started fine but it's very likely you did the battery no favours at all being sat at 100% for 3 months. The fact it started fine is not an indication that it was not a problem to do that.

How about the fact after having it for 3 years and 24,000 miles it still provided the same 190 mile summer range?

Don't these Hyundai's have a top buffer?
 

· Registered
Joined
·
891 Posts
I thought I'd check the LG cell docs for this common situation and there are relevant performance graphs but they only go up to 90% SoC(BMS) at a realistic 25°C, and I only have them in monochrome so you can't ascertain which lines are for what SoC. This is actually the 2018-1019 recalled cell but I think the current chemistry is still the same and this data should be equally applicable.

Essentially both temperature over 45°C and higher stored SoC levels both appear to be the main factors that increase degradation. But, the time periods here are in weeks rather than days so you could leave it at 100% (displayed) for 2 days dozens of times before making any measurable difference, noting also that 100% SoC displayed is really only about 95% per the BMS values referred to in the graphs.
Font Line Rectangle Parallel Pattern
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,174 Posts
It'll be fine. We got our Ioniq just before first lockdown in 2020, it was sat at 100% for the duration (3 months?) and no problems at all after, started first time, even 12v was okay.
"Started first time" WTF?
The issue is long periods at 100% causing battery degradation, not breaking the car completely!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
383 Posts
"Started first time" WTF?
The issue is long periods at 100% causing battery degradation, not breaking the car completely!
As in, I was worried it wouldn't even start... And general tales of 12v issues, but neither were an immediate issue.

I understand the question was about long term degradation, but the OP leaving his car at 100% (which isn't 100% anyway), for a couple of days is a non issue.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
946 Posts
Clearly chicken little is alive and well.

Obviously charging the car to 100% for 2 whole days is simply wreckless and will ruin your battery. WTF are you thinking? Why are you charging it at all? Why are you using the car? Don’t you know that the only way the battery will last is to charge it st the slowest possible rate and just leave the battery partially discharged constantly? DO NOT UsE YOUR CAR. Stay at home and invest in a hugely expensive battery monitor and a massive bottle of pills that keep you awake so you never miss a tiny variation in the state of charge and take out a millenium long warranty extension just in case. Above all, WORRY about it. Worry about it a lot. That’s what being an EV driver from 2012 is all about.

Seriously, it’ll be fine.
 
1 - 20 of 52 Posts
Top