[Jono63]

I appreciate this is my own fault, but I’m sharing, to warn other.

This morning, I reached to move the drive selector from “D” to “B” - unfortunately at the very moment, I suddenly sneezed and managed to catch / press the “P button on the end.

The car braked very hard, so much that I was thrown forward. I accept that its my fault, but I’m surprised the car allowed it to happen. I’ve driven cars with auto parking breaks previously and I’m fairly certain they wouldn’t have activated - I know in my last car that if I pressed the park break too soon, it got cross and came up with a message.

Thankfully I was only travelling at about 20, with no one behind, so no real harm done. It could have been very different if I’d been travelling faster.

 

[cah197]

I wonder what speed the Park button disarms?

 

[Jono63]

I wonder what speed the Park button disarms?

Or if my experience is yet another software issue 😂

 

[6652]

Seems like you enabled the emergency braking button. See the manual;

Seems there is not a speed over which it won’t work.

It is quite difficult to accidentally press the Park button for a prolonged time though, if you just caught it in a sneeze it would be the same as momentarily pressing the foot brake in the same scenario.

 

[Jono63]

Seems like you enabled the emergency braking button. See the manual;

View attachment 142794

Seems there is not a speed over which it won’t work.

It is quite difficult to accidentally press the Park button for a prolonged time though, if you just caught it in a sneeze it would be the same as momentarily pressing the foot brake in the same scenario.

It definitely wasn’t a long press, it was the joint on my thumb that caught it, definitely less that a second.

Anyway, I’ve learnt my lesson - no more sneezing whilst driving 😂

 

[cah197]

Seems there is not a speed over which it won’t work.

 

[LS99]

It definitely wasn’t a long press, it was the joint on my thumb that caught it, definitely less that a second.

Anyway, I’ve learnt my lesson - no more sneezing whilst driving 😂

Wow - thanks for the "warning" / "advise" ... I frequently shift between D and B ... and I can see how easy it would be to "catch" the "Parking button" !

Glad you're ok ! and yes - no sneezing allowed !

 

[6652]

I suppose people need to treat it like a manual handbrake, and you do have to press the P in and hold it to brake to a stop.

 

[Sandy]

Well I'm surmising you also didn't have time to hook the crook of your elbow around your face before you splattered all over the dash and windscreen. Time to get the anti-bac wipes out. 🤮

 

[Jono63]

I suppose people need to treat it like a manual handbrake, and you do have to press the P in and hold it to brake to a stop.

Yes, definitely seems like it needs treating like a manual handbrake. My only comment being that it’s much more difficult to pull a manual handbrake on in error, I’ve not managed in over 30 years, whereas I managed this in 30 days.

 

[Jono63]

Well I'm surmising you also didn't have time to hook the crook of your elbow around your face before you splattered all over the dash and windscreen. Time to get the anti-bac wipes out. 🤮

Interestingly it wasn’t that type of sneeze. It came from nowhere and was more of a sneeze reaction than anything else - thankfully no wipes needed

 

[Prof.X]

I appreciate this is my own fault, but I’m sharing, to warn other.

This morning, I reached to move the drive selector from “D” to “B” - unfortunately at the very moment, I suddenly sneezed and managed to catch / press the “P button on the end.

The car braked very hard, so much that I was thrown forward. I accept that its my fault, but I’m surprised the car allowed it to happen. I’ve driven cars with auto parking breaks previously and I’m fairly certain they wouldn’t have activated - I know in my last car that if I pressed the park break too soon, it got cross and came up with a message.

Thankfully I was only travelling at about 20, with no one behind, so no real harm done. It could have been very different if I’d been travelling faster.

Did the park brake actually engaged or it just braked hard for a moment?

 

[Paul-H]

So... can you handbrake turn an id3? You first 😆

 

[Jono63]

Did the park brake actually engaged or it just braked hard for a moment?

As far as I can tell, the park brake fully engaged. I was thrown forward, there was a fairly loud clunk and the car came to a stop, I can’t be sure if the “P” illuminated on the console, to be honest, I was a bit shaken up.

 

[Jono63]

So... can you handbrake turn an id3? You first 😆

I’m supposed to be getting a loan ID3 soon, I’ll let you know - don’t want to try in my own 😂

 

[Woodulike]

I've pressed P momentarily by mistake and got a error message saying I was going too fast to engage the brake, or words to that effect.
Didn't try sneezing while I had pressing thought, maybe that's the difference

 

[loggamatt]

Long press as per the manual sounds fine, short tap less so! Hopefully if it is engaging on a short tap on some cars, that's just another software bug that will be fixed in time.

 

[Jono63]

Long press as per the manual sounds fine, short tap less so! Hopefully if it is engaging on a short tap on some cars, that's just another software bug that will be fixed in time.

If some cars get a warning message, it does suggest a software problem. Thankfully I wasn’t going faster, if I had been, I could have been killed by a software error. VW would however be OK, as they could just delete the error from the log and no one would know 😂

 

[loggamatt]

If some cars get a warning message, it does suggest a software problem. Thankfully I wasn’t going faster, if I had been, I could have been killed by a software error. VW would however be OK, as they could just delete the error from the log and no one would know 😂

I expect VW would send your surviving relatives Kansalis/Phlashman-style hampers though...

 

[Alex Lake]

I appreciate this is my own fault, but I’m sharing, to warn other.

This morning, I reached to move the drive selector from “D” to “B” - unfortunately at the very moment, I suddenly sneezed and managed to catch / press the “P button on the end.

The car braked very hard, so much that I was thrown forward. I accept that its my fault, but I’m surprised the car allowed it to happen. I’ve driven cars with auto parking breaks previously and I’m fairly certain they wouldn’t have activated - I know in my last car that if I pressed the park break too soon, it got cross and came up with a message.

Thankfully I was only travelling at about 20, with no one behind, so no real harm done. It could have been very different if I’d been travelling faster.

I've often thought that sneezing while driving is dangerous. It's amazing how long you close your eyes for,