Speak EV - Electric Car Forums banner

R90 vs R110 Performance/Range?

22K views 55 replies 18 participants last post by  PeteKS  
#1 ·
Happy owner of a BMW i3. Wife soon to take this off my hands. Have always like the Zoe and impressed with the 40kwh battery but on test drive found it a bit sluggish. 0-30mph felt good enough. 40+ seemed to be a bit of a struggle although it cruised well enough at 65mph.

Therefore I am interested in test driving the 110 version, which hopefully will take place next week. Demo cars seem a bit thin on the ground at present at dealers, where I live.

I am more than a little aware that a new Zoe version with bigger battery and CCS may well be coming-end of the year or early 2020 (just like everything else EV it seems!!), but I figure, it will be more expensive, there may well be some teething problems with all the tech and there will not be that many great offers around at release time, I suspect.

Whereas there are plenty of fantastic offers on this version of Zoe at present. The dealer I spoke to today was pretty much honest in saying the new S version is Renault's way of shifting the soon to be replaced body asap as are the no cost optional 17" wheels which come from the Clio which is also soon to be replaced with a new model in the coming weeks.

A present model Zoe 40 R110 will I feel be enough for my daily commute/weekly living + the i3 has CCS for longer journeys. Still have my 6 year old great little VW Up! but once you drive electric is very hard to go back to a "chugging" ICE car, and the Zoe is still quieter, smoother & faster as is, in and around town/A roads.

Is the R110 a bit more "brisk" at higher speeds? Does it have more torque than the R90 version? Does it affect the range much? Have they sorted the heater issue on newer models?
Pros and cons in general? Does it have split fold rear seats now?

Regards,
MM
 
#2 ·
The R90 has a 92bhp motor versus the R110 with a 108bhp motor so there is a bit more power available but I don't know how much difference this makes in the real world. I believe the range should be about the same with both the R90/R110 having 5-10% more than the Q90 (now discontinued). All new Zoes have had split rear seats since late 2018 now so you'd only need to check if you're buying a used/ex-demo.

Not sure about the heater issues, there are plenty of Zoes out there that are fine. You're in an echo chamber here because it's probably the first place you're going to post if you have issues with your heater.
 
#4 ·
Up until roughly 20 mph ZOE is torque limited, not power limited. After that, it's full power and consequently, torque tampers off (power = torque * speed). So, 0-20 there is no difference, but an R110 will simply be on full torque a bit longer and higher torque all the way up. I have seen at least one driver here saying the difference is absolutely noticeable. Given it's roughly 20% I bet that is true. I have not heard any reports that the (software) limited maximum speed is anything different, which makes sense; the hardware basically hits it's RPM limit.
 
#6 ·
Still faster than my ford sports KA and my father in laws toyota estima ;)

It’s all relative

Even the mega fast Tesla’s top out and get eaten up over more than a 1/4 mile

JJ
 
#10 ·
All sounds great. Thanks for the feedback. My journey to work here in South Wales involves climbing over a mountain. So do that twice a day. Sounds like the R110 will do it with ease.
In the VW Up if you lose momentum you have to drop to second gear. My i3 positively scoots up the mountain as if on the flat.
 
#14 ·
Had the test drive today of the R110 and to be honest it was excellent. The Zoe is still a lovely car to drive (suspension supple enough), and quiet like all EVs and actually handles ok (with all the battery weight down low).

Now with the R110 this car is fast enough. Took it over the mountain x 2 and it accelerates really well. Up a steep incline no problem at all. Not i3 fast but definitely fast enough in comparison with the 90 version and the 110 cruised easily at 70mph with 40-70mph acceleration definitely now fast enough.

Dealer has located some final Signature Navs coming in. The newer S models will be factory orders so 2-3 month wait apparently.
He is pushing me for a battery lease version which I am not too keen on but there seems to be pros and cons to both "i" and "battery rental" options.Already read through those forum pages!

He is offering a decent discount (dealer contribution etc) off a Sig.ZE40 R110 to around ÂŁhigh teens + battery rental. Is that any good? Think list price is around ÂŁ25k.

Still tempting to hang fire and wait for the Zoe 2 at end of year or most likely 2020 with CCS and great range and nicer interior, but then I guess it will be more expensive again.
 
#16 ·
Had the test drive today of the R110 and to be honest it was excellent. The Zoe is still a lovely car to drive (suspension supple enough), and quiet like all EVs and actually handles ok (with all the battery weight down low).

Now with the R110 this car is fast enough. Took it over the mountain x 2 and it accelerates really well. Up a steep incline no problem at all. Not i3 fast but definitely fast enough in comparison with the 90 version and the 110 cruised easily at 70mph with 40-70mph acceleration definitely now fast enough.

Dealer has located some final Signature Navs coming in. The newer S models will be factory orders so 2-3 month wait apparently.
He is pushing me for a battery lease version which I am not too keen on but there seems to be pros and cons to both "i" and "battery rental" options.Already read through those forum pages!

He is offering a decent discount (dealer contribution etc) off a Sig.ZE40 R110 to around ÂŁhigh teens + battery rental. Is that any good? Think list price is around ÂŁ25k.

Still tempting to hang fire and wait for the Zoe 2 at end of year or most likely 2020 with CCS and great range and nicer interior, but then I guess it will be more expensive again.
I've ordered a Sig, with lease, went via CarWow and best price was about ÂŁ16k PCP and that included paint. Prices fluctuate a lot though of course. How long a wait are they saying on these 'final Sigs'? I didnt think much of the S model when it was released, you pay more and dont get a great deal more whereas Sig included all the bits you'd want (i.e. heated seats, Bose etc). I guess you would be at least a year away from getting a Zoe 2 considering time to release date plus a long wait with all the demand it will generate, then once you're about to get it there'll be another one about to be released with even further range!
 
#15 ·
My car (battery lease) is worth 22K I got it for ÂŁ12,500 so yes that's good. The day might come when you run out of charge and be glad you have the lease (or the battery dies and you haven't got 5K for a new one) I drove past someone in an i the other week who was flat - and so they were stuck unless they had their own breakdown. I prefer it all being built in to the monthlies
 
#18 ·
I debated lease or ownership for ages. I dont think its an easy choice one way or the other. In the end as a first EV driver and with EV's still in their relative infancy i decided i wanted the reassurance. That's what you're paying for really as well as cheaper up front costs which are mainly a benefit for a short-term PCP deal. If all goes well ill likely get an owned model next time and that's the way the industry will go as battery reliance is proven long term and prices drop.
 
#17 ·
I think the risk with waiting for Zoe 2 (aka 2020 model) is that they will reduce discounts yet again (*) and PICG could reduce again, so double wammy.

* - If rumours are true it will be have a 200 mile range which will increase demand, so why discount so much?

If the R110 does what you want, then I would be tempted to get one ASAP. Do check prices on Carwow and there were some pre-reg available too.

And yeah, let's not get back into a lease vs. owned battery debate yet again. Both have pros and cons...

Good luck!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tony1
#20 ·
Thanks all. Yes the whole point of the government grant was to make "going green" more attractive/cheaper. And without doubt it is taking off, going by EV sales figures and manufacturers saying they are now going all out electric for future models, so they will probably reduce the grant again before the end of this year and stop it completely soon after.
I do have breakdown cover with my car insurance at present but also with my bank so I guess I will be covered for that eventuality. I thought the whole reason Renault did this rental model was because at the beginning, the public were a bit worried about how long EV battery packs would last. Now with so much data with Teslas taxis doing 400,000 miles+, surely there is little to worry about. And more pertinently I do not plan to keep this or any car for that long or for that type of mileage anyway! The car still has a 3 year warranty. I have a feeling they will drop the battery rental model with Zoe2 because of that, but in some respects it is a nice little earner for Renault, helping to keep you "tied in".
Dealer just got back to me. An i Signature ( and you are right the Signature does seem fully loaded with decent spec!) for April delivery for just over ÂŁ23k. Any good? Will have to do a Carwow search now to compare.
MM
 
#21 · (Edited)
Renault Zoe Owners Club have deals with some dealers - If you join (for free) you should be able to access better prices than on CarWow.

[Edited to remove actual deal details as requested]
 
  • Like
Reactions: cah197
#25 ·
There were some pre-reg Zoe Signature on Carwow but looks like they sold. As others have said, factory orders have stopped for Signature now that "S" model has been released.
 
#23 ·
Can't see you'll be able to get a Sig via carwow as it's a model they no longer do. Prob would need to go direct to a dealer.

Taxis doing 10ks miles with original battery but they do short journeys typically so battery health can go low. The lease is not just maintaining the battery, it's guaranteeing it to 75% so you should always get around 100 miles plus in perpetuity, that's what tempted me with the lease. That said its increasingly sounding like you'd still expect a good 10 years I guess with no lower than 70/ 80%
 
#24 · (Edited)
its increasingly sounding like you'd still expect a good 10 years I guess with no lower than 70/ 80%
Maybe, but you can't take data on Tesla packs and chemistry and apply it to other makes. Zoe ZE40 are not very old yet, so it is difficult to predict risk of age-related capacity loss and failure. Early Leaf models are starting to show a lot of degradation and Zoe 22kWh did until the "magic" BMS update (for which there are plenty of threads already).

The battery owned Zoe ZE40 have 8 year, 100K warranty, so it really is a case of people making their own decision on upfront vs. ongoing cost. We don't need to go back around it again - please :rolleyes:

Incidentally, with regard to generic breakdown cover, bear in mind a lot of policies are unlikely to provide flatbed recovery if you run out of electric.
 
#27 ·
Hopefully they do it properly with a flatbed, although some people claim you can tow a Zoe if the battery is flat. Anyone actually had them do it?
 
#31 ·
After getting all excited and looking at figures etc decided to hold off. Purely as I came to the conclusion, that the Zoe although excellent at what it does, is at the end of its natural life cycle, and is soon to be replaced, as well as plenty of other competitors on the very near horizon (Peugeot 208 e etc).
Fast 100kwh CCS, true 200+ mile range and the option to have niceties such as LED headlamps etc are important after all. I felt I would always kick myself and say "why didn't I just wait a few more weeks/months" if I bought this version of the Zoe now.
Still really like the Zoe as it is, but it IS very expensive! For what it offers.
And I just get the feeling if the government grant does go, I suspect manufacturers will drop their prices accordingly!
Renault,Peugeot, Citroen etc cannot alienate their typical customer base with very expensive electric cars after all. Or at least that is what I feel. I believe the Zoe 2 will be a pretty similar price to the current Zoe but feel more like a 21st century product than Zoe 1.
MM
 
#33 ·
I understand that totally but it is a 6 year old model. The Zoe1 is a lovely cruiser on the motorway. Even with its present range would still be a great cruiser but as not CCS/Chademo etc it would be a big hassle taking further afield.
It limits its appeal. This would not be the case 4 years ago when there were hardly any comparable EVs around but now everything will soon be CCS enabled and so this really remains a commuter car (and it is still brilliant at that) but why own something so one dimensional, when we are about to have such multi use (normal use) EVs now being released.
It boiled down to price as well. ÂŁ31k+ RRP which is kinda crazy. It is a city car after all. Yes the dealer discount was large but....
For an EV, it still has character though!