Speak EV - Electric Car Forums banner

Argument with Renault UK about parts under warranty

5.4K views 18 replies 10 participants last post by  dk6780  
#1 ·
Hello all.
New to the forum and hoping someone technical can advise me.

Short story:
Does anyone know if, on a 2017 Renault Zoe R90, the "Charge Filter unit" Or the "Module Charger In" is part of the Powertrain?

Longer story:
I have a 2017 Renault Zoe, leased battery..
45k miles in first 3 years, about 2k since March 2020!!
Had 3 year warranty, extended at end of that for 1 year, but then told Icouldn't extend further (I now believe I should have been able to, that's another story...) so out of Warranty since March 2021..
I do however have a 5 year Powertrain warranty, to March 2022.

About a month ago Zoe stopped charging, at home and public points, with msg to '...check plug'.
Got it into local Renault service centre for Diagnostics (ÂŁ130!). Initially told diagnostics could not tell what was wrong.
Then after a few days told it was the "Charge Filter unit" but that has now changed to being the "Module Charger In". ( I do not know if this is the same or not!)
Kindly reminded me that I am unfortunately out of warranty so that will be Approx ÂŁ2200 to fix incl. labour and Rishi's cut.

When I asked if this is part of the powertrain I was told "Probably not", and then simply that "no its separate". When pushed, they could not tell me where this part fitted in the whole system that made it separate, and was all just too vague. (Really, I would be happy if someone could explain, with schematics - What is faulty and where it fits and why it is therefore separate from the Powertrain - but immediately suspicious because the answers have been vague and inconsistent.)

I contacted Renault customer service (as advised to by service centre) who frankly have been useless. Took a week to return the promised call, even after Me chasing them a few times.
My request to them was to please explain the Powertrain and why these parts are separate.
Essentially their response is "They've spoken to the service centre, and It's What they said!". At least I know they have indeed spoken to the service centre.

Trawling online hasn't turned up that much info that helps answer my Q one way or the other.
There is however this video online, direct From Renault itself, and to my untrained eye this shows pretty much everything from the inlet plug to the motor clearly described as "The Powertrain"

Can anyone help confirm if the faulty parts are definitively in or out of the Powertrain?
Does that video show what I think it does - from inlet plug to motor as The Powertrain
Any help or advice greatfully accepted.

...And Nil Points to Renault Customer Blah Blah.

Thanks all,
btonEV.
 
#2 ·
Welcome to the Brave New World of EVs.

Renault UK haven't got a clue how their cars are designed. They'll tell you anything, and will happily say something is both broken AND that it is meant to work like that. "They all do that, mate, innit" is their general response.

Keep a log of all your communications and get ready for a complaint to the Motor Ombudsman. The best course of action for your peace of mind and minimum stress (assuming your bank balance can tolerate it) is to request a formal quote for the work, provide a written objection to the cost but that you will pay it, however you will appeal the costs to the Motor Ombudsman.

That way, you are only writing one letter to RUK and one to the Motor Ombudsman, and you can get on with your life and avoid having to continually stress over a broken down car wondering what you should do about it.

Just IMHO ...

Once it is all fixed and you are in a position to do so, get shot of the car and get something else. Owning a Zoe is something I would only recommend to my evil enemies.
 
#4 ·
Renault like to weasel out of the warranty if possible.
Yep. They actually employ weasels, most of whom have done a Masters in Professional Weaseling Studies at Weasel University in Weasleton, and are encouraged to join as professional members of the Institute of Double Gobbledygook and Weasel Words.

Well, I think that's true, "AFAIK"?
 
#7 ·
The warranty document online suggests this is what the powertrain warranty covers:

Electric powertrain consists of:
1 - Motor
2 - Reduction Gear
3 - Charger - box interconnection
4 - EVC Controller
5 - Inverter
6 - DCDC converter
7 - Connecting high voltage cables between these components

I agree with the poster above - try Cleevely EV and see what they say - if not covered by the warranty they may at least be able to offer a replacement at a lower cost.

There may also be a HEVRA garage closer to you who can help.
 
#9 ·
Not really sure but on observation a lot seems to depend on the dealer. They're the first line and often just refuse people at the outset, and then HQ back them up. Or say yeah we'll cover it, and also get backed up.

Probably worth asking in RZOC if you're on Facebook (they also have a traditional forum, I'm not sure many people use it). Various people either working for Renault or in close contact with them post there and if you do have a good argument they'll know which strings to pull. Could possibly involve getting it transferred to somewhere like DSG in Morecambe, one of the club dealers, as if it CAN be covered then they're pretty honest about it.

Or indeed CleeveleyEV
 
#10 ·
Not really sure but on observation a lot seems to depend on the dealer. They're the first line and often just refuse people at the outset, and then HQ back them up. Or say yeah we'll cover it, and also get backed up.
Yep.

Or vice versa.

Which implies what? It means dealers and concessionaires don't know what they are talking about half the time.

Ask here if you want the actual answer to ANY question related to BEVs, but don't expect dealers and concessionaires to agree with it, because they like to guess!! ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: ElectricIan
#12 ·
Sounds to me like those parts are being given pseudonyms so that o/p won't realise they are in the power train.

Also, it's possible they could say that a particular part not covered by the guarantee was faulty, charge you for that, but actually replace a part that is covered by the guarantee. Thus turning a guarantee repair into a chargeable repair.
 
#13 ·
I agree the OP should request full details, he paid for the diagnostic so the output should be at the level of written professional detail, not a fob-off on the 'phone.

Like I said, that doesn't actually matter right now if the OP wants the least-mental-stress route, which is simply to pay the piper in the first instance along with a note of objection to the repair costs.

What he paid for is then all in B&W and there is no mistaking what part of the car it was.
 
#14 ·
That would be fraud, but is not unknown. Always ask for the replaced parts and dispose of them yourself to avoid them being reused.
Paranoid? Just because I am doesn't mean that they aren't out to get you.
 
#15 ·
Paranoid? Just because I am doesn't mean that they aren't out to get you.
It's the ones who aren't paranoid that have something to worry about. ... Oh, errr .. :unsure:
 
  • Like
Reactions: dk6780
#17 ·
There's a common-ish issue with Zoe where one of the relays in the BCB "welds" itself shut when connected to a faulty 3 phase charge point. However I thought that it was prevented by 2017 production but @yoh-there the expert on Zoe will be able to confirm.
Out of interest, did you try a public charge point the time before this issue started? If so, the repair is quite cheap* for a specialist like Clevely.
* Three figures rather than four.
 
#18 ·
If that relay is welded, it will blow the fuses of any 3 phase charger. It will charge single phase. If the relay or control circuit is broken, it will simply not charge on one phase, but will on 3 phase. Seen both (not on mine, but first hand accounts, latter case I witnessed myself on a mate's ZOE). Yes the issue of a faultily wired chargepoint being able to weld the relay was fixed in software, bit I don't know the exact date. A fairly good guess it is fixed with the software pack that includes 0854 on the LBC. CanZE is your friend here (SSP).

If your car is fixed under warranty, you will a,most certainly not get hold of the replaced parts. AFAIK they are returned to Renault. Makes sense to me, they can, at their convenience of course, decide to post-mortem them.

To answer the OP's question: The Filter unit (which contains said relay) is absolutely an integrated part of the power-train. I doubt it helps me saying that, but there it is. The cable from the filter to the nose could be debatable I guess. Expensive thingy BTW.
 
#19 ·
@btonEV
That's the most accurate advice that you'll get. You should fight this hard - push the garage and Renault hard. Clearly they should be paying. And let us know how you get on and what the fault is.